Clear Vibrations

Quakertown, PA's Mobile Enhancement Headquarters

550 California Road Suite 7
Quakertown, PA 18951
267-227-3875
  • Home
  • Services
    • Car Audio
    • Custom Installation
    • Driver Safety
    • Fleet Services
    • Remote Car Starters
  • About Us
    • Work for Clear Vibrations
  • Reviews
  • Location
  • Contact Us
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Sealed or Vented Car Audio Subwoofer Enclosures: What’s the Difference?

Sealed Vented Subwoofer

When it comes to car audio subwoofer enclosures, the two most popular options are sealed or vented. As far as which design is best for your vehicle, let’s see if we can clear up some misconceptions and stereotypes. As often happens, some trade-offs accompany each decision. Consider this article the master reference for choosing the right subwoofer enclosure solution for your application.

Why Does a Subwoofer Need an Enclosure?

Let’s review a few key factors about subwoofers (and speakers in general). First and foremost, the primary purpose of a subwoofer enclosure is to prevent the sound that’s coming off the back of the speaker cone from mixing with the sound coming from the front. If these two mix, they cancel each other out almost perfectly. If you’ve ever held a subwoofer in your hand without an enclosure while it’s playing, you’ll know it doesn’t produce much sound.

Second, an enclosure acts as a mechanical high-pass filter that limits low-frequency output. Why do we need to limit bass from a subwoofer? As frequency decreases, cone excursion increases dramatically to produce an equivalent output. In fact, for every halving of frequency, cone excursion doubles.

Sealed Vented Subwoofer
Cone excursion vs. frequency for a subwoofer without an enclosure.

The simulation above shows the predicted cone excursion (in millimeters) of an audiophile-grade 10-inch subwoofer without an enclosure. This is a great driver, and it has an Xmax specification of 19 mm. As such, at frequencies below 22 hertz, when driven with 500 watts of power, the distortion would skyrocket. If we increase the power to the subwoofer to 750 watts, that frequency increases to 28 hertz. At a drive level of 1,000 watts, the driver will reach its Xmax limit at 33 hertz.

Many subwoofers don’t have this much excursion capability, so we need to limit the distance the cone can move. We install the subwoofer in an enclosure so that the air in the enclosure combines with the suspension of the driver to limit cone motion. More specifically, we are adding the stiffness of the air spring in the enclosure to the stiffness of the subwoofer suspension (spider and surround) to make the net system stiffer. Here’s the predicted cone excursion of this driver in the manufacturer-recommend 0.6-cubic-foot enclosure.

Sealed Vented Subwoofer
Cone excursion of a 10-inch audiophile-grade subwoofer in a 0.6-cubic-foot sealed enclosure in yellow.

This second graph shows that the driver’s excursion is limited to about 11.7 millimeters when driven with 500 watts. Excursion increases to only 16.5 millimeters at the lowest frequencies when fed 1,000 watts. In this enclosure, cone excursion is no longer an issue.

The trade-off for limited cone excursion is a decrease in output capability. The graph below shows the predicted frequency response of our subwoofer system in the infinite baffle simulation and the small sealed enclosure.

Sealed Vented Subwoofer
Infinite baffle response in red, sealed enclosure response in yellow.

Below 47 hertz, the infinite baffle driver becomes more efficient. For example, at 25 Hz, it’s 3.6 dB louder in the infinite baffle.

Subwoofer Cone Excursion and Distortion

More output seems ideal, as long as we are below the Xmax limit, right? Well, yes and no. Every moving coil speaker produces more distortion as cone excursion increases. In addition, variations in suspension compliance (the inverse of stiffness) and magnetic field strength mean that the cone may not track the input signal accurately at high excursion levels. Given the above considerations, we want to limit cone excursion whenever possible. As such, more or larger diameter subwoofers in a system can improve sound quality, as long as each is in a correctly designed enclosure.

Let’s add the bass reflex (also known as ported or vented) enclosure to the mix. A vented enclosure is similar to our sealed enclosure, except it has a tube (or square, triangle or rectangle) with a specific length and area. The vent is a Helmholtz resonator. What’s that? Have you ever blown across the top of a bottle of pop (OK, soda) to hear it hum? That’s a Helmholtz resonator. The resonant frequency is lower if you drink some of the pop and blow again. This is because you’re exciting the air in the chamber, and it resonates at a specific frequency. Helmholtz resonators are used on the intact ducting and exhaust systems of cars to cancel out resonances in the system.

In a vented subwoofer enclosure, the vibration from the subwoofer cone causes the column of air in the vent to resonate. At a specific frequency, called the tuning frequency, the resonance in the vent is maximized. As a result, the vent now acts as the primary sound source for the enclosure, and output from the subwoofer cone itself is minimal. Here’s the cone excursion graph of our audiophile-grade 10-inch subwoofer in a 1-cubic-foot vented enclosure that has a vent tuned to resonate at 33 hertz.

Sealed Vented Subwoofer
Predicted subwoofer cone excursion in a 1-cubic-foot enclosure tuned to 33 hertz in green.

We can see that cone excursion is dramatically increased around the tuning frequency of 33 hertz. It increases slightly at 60 hertz, but in this design, that’s inconsequential. What does matter is that the vent acts like a hole in the enclosure at low frequencies, and cone excursion increased dramatically below 27 hertz. If we want to maximize the output of the system, the use of an electronic infrasonic filter will be necessary at 25 hertz.

What’s the benefit of our vented enclosure, then? Here’s the predicted output graph.

Sealed Vented Subwoofer
Predicted frequency response of our audiophile-grade 10-inch subwoofer in a 1-cubic-foot vented enclosure tuned to 33 Hz in green.

As you can see, we gained an impressive 6.5 dB of output at 40 hertz for the same input power. We’d need to drive the sealed subwoofer with 2,235 watts to produce the same output. For many reasons, including the risk of fire, that won’t work.

Sealed vs. Vented – Enclosure Size

In the case of this example, the sealed enclosure has a net internal air volume of 0.6 cubic foot. Our vented enclosure is 1 cubic foot. Translated into dimensions, the outside dimensions of the sealed enclosure, constructed of ¾-inch MDF, would be (as an example) 12 by 12 by 11.75 inches. The vented enclosure would need to be 12 by 12 by 18.2 inches. That’s an increase in length of more than 50%. If you need a small enclosure to fit in a specific space, sealed might be your only option.

Sealed vs. Vented – Efficiency

Comparing the two enclosures above clarifies that the vented design is significantly louder at all frequencies above 18.5 hertz. So, if you’re looking for the most output from a system with a small amplifier, then a vented enclosure is the best choice. The vented enclosure is the best choice if you’re after the loudest system.

Sealed vs. Vented – Sound Quality

When it comes to outright sound quality, choosing your enclosure is more complicated. We’ll need to start by looking at what happens when we put these enclosures into a vehicle. The graph below shows two traces for each enclosure. The lower trace of each color is the free-field predicted response, and the second trace includes an approximation of the response of the system in a car or SUV. This in-car response information is based on data that Boston Acoustics included with one of their drivers in the BassBox Pro simulation software I use. I’ve seen in-car graphs from other sources that are similar, so this is adequate for our purposes.

Sealed Vented Subwoofer
Comparison of free-field vs. in-car frequency response.

As you can see, at low frequencies, based on the provided information, a significant amount of boost is added. It’s on the order of more than 20 dB SPL below 30 hertz. What looked like a smooth, flat response from the vented enclosure now has a prominent peak from 30 to 45 hertz. What looked like somewhat limited output from the sealed enclosure appears reasonably flat.

Here’s the answer to choosing sealed or vented for sound quality. If the system doesn’t have an equalizer to flatten the response, then a sealed enclosure would be better. If the system does have an equalizer, then choose a vented enclosure. Why choose the vented design when there is an EQ? Well, you can flatten the response and dramatically reduce the power required from your amplifier to hit a target response curve. More importantly, cone excursion will be decreased dramatically with the vented enclosure so that less distortion will be added to the sound produced by the subwoofer.

One quick note: For the last statement to be true, the vent in the enclosure needs to be designed and executed correctly. That’s a topic for an entirely different article.

Sealed vs. Vented – Infrasonic Performance

Many people really like deep bass. I’m not talking about 25 or 30 hertz; I mean 10 to 15 hertz bass. The kind that you don’t hear but feel in your back and behind. If that’s your cup of tea, then a sealed enclosure might be the better option for your car audio system.

Sealed vs. Vented – Limited Xmax Subwoofers

If you want to have an enclosure constructed for a subwoofer with limited excursion capability, you might want to consider the vented design. This might be an entry-level subwoofer with a short magnetic field or a shallow-mount subwoofer.

Sealed vs. Vented – Enclosure Construction Cost

This one will be up to the specialty mobile enhancement retailer you’re working with. The cost of constructing a vented enclosure is likely higher than for a sealed design. With that said, the performance benefits may offset this cost. You might want to read our article about choosing subwoofer sizes as a single 12 in a vented enclosure might outperform two 10-inch subs in a sealed enclosure. The net cost should be much less. Talk to the product specialist you’re working with and have them do some simulations with the drivers you have in mind.

Pick Your Priorities, Then Pick Your Enclosure

There you go – a whole slew of reasons why you might pick a sealed enclosure or a vented one for your car audio subwoofer. Depending on your application and expectations, there isn’t a clear winner. Make a list of what you want from a subwoofer, then cross-reference those criteria with the answers above. If you reach a stalemate, prioritize your criteria and repeat the process. Your local specialty mobile enhancement retailer should have no problem delivering a solution that will sound great based on that list.

This article is written and produced by the team at www.BestCarAudio.com. Reproduction or use of any kind is prohibited without the express written permission of 1sixty8 media.

Filed Under: ARTICLES, Car Audio, RESOURCE LIBRARY

Gain Overlap, and Why It Matters in Configuring Car Audio Amplifiers

Gain Overlap

Ah, the oh-so-complex world of amplifier sensitivity control configuration. One would think that there would be a scientific process that would ensure that an amplifier could be set perfectly every time. But in reality, many criteria affect where a sensitivity control is adjusted. The topic of gain overlap pertains equally to source units as amplifiers. What is it? Why do we need it? Let’s find out.

Amplifier Sensitivity Settings

The purpose of the sensitivity (or gain) setting on an amplifier is to allow it to be matched with a variety of source options. For example, if you have a 100-watts-per-channel stereo amp and a radio that can produce 2 volts of output on the RCAs, the amplifier needs to have more signal gain than if the radio made 5 volts of output. However, the maximum undistorted power output remains at 100 watts no matter where the sensitivity control is configured.

A few things to think about as we dive deeper into this discussion. In 99% of cases, technicians use a 0 dB track at a specific frequency to set sensitivity controls. If the amplifier is powering a subwoofer or feeding a full-range signal to a speaker, this method should do a good job of preventing any clipping of the outputs. However, if the amp is used with a high-pass filter to power a set of midrange speakers, there’s an entirely different procedure to find an optimum setting.

Second, music isn’t always recorded at the loudest possible level. Modern music is close, though. Let’s look at a few tracks to get an idea of this concept.

First is the amplitude-based analysis of “Galway Girl” by Ed Sheeran.

Gain Overlap

As you can see, the song is recorded at a reasonably high volume and maintains a high average volume. Having a look at the statistics shows us that the maximum recording level is -0.09 dB, very close to the maximum possible level of 0 dB. The average level for the song is -9.65 dB, as shown below.

Gain Overlap

Let’s look at another track. This time we’ll analyze “Easy on me” by Adele.

Gain Overlap

Not surprisingly, this song doesn’t appear quite as loud – that is, until the drums come in at 1:27 into the song. You can see just how much her voice is compressed to the maximum level of -0.20 dB. The average level for this track is a little lower at -12.28 dB.

Gain Overlap

Let’s go back a few decades and see how music was recorded before the “loudness wars” resulted in produces and engineers boosting levels to make voices stand out on the radio. Here’s “Hungry Like the Wolf” by Duran Duran.

Gain Overlap

This track dramatically represents how the average loudness of modern songs has been boosted. You can see lots of black space below the 0 dB peak.

Gain Overlap

The peak level for this track remains high at 0 dB on the right channel, but now our average level is way down around -20 dB. In terms of how loud the song seems, this would be 8 to 10 dB lower than something modern.

Last and certainly not least, let’s look at “Brothers in Arms” by Dire Straits. It shouldn’t be news to anyone listening to this album that it has a low recording level. Or does it?

Gain Overlap

As you can see in the statistics below, the average RMS level of this track is way down around -24 dB. If you want this loud, you’ll need to turn up the volume a little more. Keep in mind, though, the maximum recording level is still high a -0.20 dB.

Gain Overlap

Introducing Gain Overlap

From a purely scientific standpoint, all of the recordings analyzed above have a very similar maximum recording level. As such, if your audio system is set up to just clip with the volume at full, it should be fine. However, in reality, we might want to be able to turn the volume up a little higher than full, so we can make quiet songs loud. This ability to turn the volume up higher is gain overlap.

Let’s say we want the average level of Duran Duran to be the same as Ed Sheeran; we need about 8 dB more gain in the system. That sounds simple enough, right? Your installer can increase the sensitivity control such that a lower input voltage will drive our 100-watt amplifier to produce full power.

All fine and dandy, right? What happens when our favorite modern song starts to play on the radio, and we crank the volume? Now we have 8 dB extra gain, and the amplifier is driving hard into clipping, adding tons of distortion. The music will sound terrible, and the additional high-frequency content (caused by clipping the outputs) can and likely will overpower the tweeters in the system and damage them.

Let’s take a look at a modern source unit. We have the Sony XAV-9500ES Mobile ES receiver set up on our test bench from its recent Test Drive Review. The built-in amplifier is configured with a typical amount of gain overlap. Playing a 0 dB test tone, the output of the amplifier reaches full power when the volume control is 44 out of 50. Add six more “notches” to make things good and loud. There is 6 dB of gain overlap in this particular radio on the built-in amplifier.

Gain Overlap
The Sony XAV-9500ES has a typical-for-a-car-radio 6 dB of gain overlap for the built-in amplifier.

Use Your Power for Good, Not Evil

So, why design or configure an audio system so that you can easily push an amplifier to the point that it distorts? We’ve discussed the technical reason already: To play quiet audio sources at the maximum output level of the amplifier. Does having gain overlap built into a system mean you can potentially damage it? Yes. Absolutely 100%, yes. As such, this means that the system operator needs to take some responsibility for how loudly it’s played. Translated, that means you have to know when you’ve reached full volume in terms of the amplifier’s output capabilities. Your installer should be able to tell you what “full volume” is for normal modern recordings, just like the 44/50 on the Sony radio. Be honest with yourself; if you aren’t going to be able to curb your enthusiasm, ask the technician working on your installation not to include any overlap.

What if you ignore our suggestion and just crank the volume? How hard is your amp going to try to work? For example, a sensitivity setting with 6 dB of overlap would make the amp try to produce 400 watts of power if you maxed out the volume with a track recorded at 0 dB.

Gain Overlap
Seventy watts per channel, or 160 watts? Audison offers a variety of solutions to let the product specialist you’re working with design a system that will perform the way you want.

How To Avoid Distortion and Play Your Music Loudly

So, what’s needed to design an audio system where the amplifiers can’t distort? The short answer is money. If you want to feed 50 watts of power to your speakers, but have the system configured with 6 dB of gain overlap, then buy a 200-watts-per-channel amp. If you want to provide your subwoofers with 500 watts of power, choose a 2,000-watt amp. Financially, this doesn’t work, does it? A good 500-watt monoblock amp might cost $650. A 2,000-watt amp of the same caliber might cost $1,500-2,000.

Gain Overlap
A customer shopping for a 300-watt amplifier isn’t going to be impressed when a product specialist suggests a 1,200-watt amp, “just in case.”

Of course, while our wallets might not like the suggestion above, that’s not the only problem. The speakers in your car or truck won’t be capable of handling four times their rated power for very long. For example, if you have a subwoofer rated for 500 watts but feet it 2,000 watts for more than a few seconds, the voice coil is likely to be damaged. Likewise, the suspension components likely aren’t designed to provide the increase in excursion that 2,000 watts of power would command.

If you want your system to play at extreme volume levels, then you’ll want more speakers or subwoofers in the system. If a set of good quality 6.5-inch component speakers and a 10-inch sub aren’t loud enough, consider adding a second set of speakers and a second subwoofer. You can also double the system’s power, so each driver works equally hard. Pushing a low to moderately rated speaker beyond its capabilities will sound bad and likely damage it. Also, overdriven speakers shouldn’t be covered under the manufacturer’s warranty. That’s not a design or component failure; it’s abuse.

When you’re at a local specialty mobile enhancement retailer discussing your audio system, be honest about your expectations. If you can’t afford the system you want, wait until you can. Purchasing less than you’ll be happy with is a good way to damage the speakers or subwoofers.

This article is written and produced by the team at www.BestCarAudio.com. Reproduction or use of any kind is prohibited without the express written permission of 1sixty8 media.

Filed Under: ARTICLES, Car Audio, RESOURCE LIBRARY

Is Dash Camera Resolution the Defining Purchasing Decision Factor?

Dash Camera Resolution

A while ago, we talked about why dashcam resolution is crucial to capturing details in the event of an accident or near-miss. The topic of dashcam image sensor resolution appears to have become a defining factor in the sales pitch from many brands. But is resolution the ultimate decision-maker when it comes to quality? Let’s take a look at some considerations.

Do You Need a 4K Dashcam?

Having a dashcam in your vehicle is important if you want to protect yourself from staged accidents, fraud or false accusations. Most basic cameras have image sensors that offer 1920×1080 resolution. That’s enough information to know whether a light was red or a car actually stopped at a stop sign. With solutions like these, you’re looking for general information about a situation.

What if there’s a hit-and-run accident, or you see someone driving dangerously and want to report it? In those cases, capturing identifying information about the vehicle and driver is paramount. Having a higher-resolution camera with a 2K 2560×1440-pixel or preferably a 4K 3840×2160-pixel image sensor dramatically increases your chance of being able to read a license plate and provide that information to the authorities.

Dash Camera Resolution
The Thinkware U1000 features an 8.24 megapixel native 4K Sony Starvis image sensor and can be upgraded with a 2K-resolution rear-facing secondary camera.

Does a 4K Dashcam Guarantee You’ll Capture a License Plate?

We’ve seen several retailers and dashcam brands promoting 4K solutions as a guarantee that you’ll be able to see a license plate. Be wary of that type of statement. If a car passes perpendicular to you, the plate will likely only be visible for a few frames of video. The same applies if it’s coming toward you. Once the vehicle is close enough for the camera to make out the letters and numbers, it will pass by very quickly. Having a high-resolution camera increases your odds of seeing a tag, but nothing guarantees you’ll capture it.

Dash Camera Resolution
The Blackvue DR750X-3CH includes forward- and rear-facing cameras with Sony sensors and a third camera with infrared illumination to capture what happens inside a vehicle.

What Other Features Affect Dashcam Image Quality?

If you’re shopping for the best camera solution, there are other considerations beyond camera resolution. For example, if you’re driving at night, then a camera with an image sensor that’s optimized for low-light levels will dramatically reduce noise in the image and help make objects clearer.

High Dynamic Range (HDR) processing is another feature that helps to brighten dark image areas and tone down parts that might be overexposed so that you can see details. In reality, this is contrast compression, but it makes a big difference when bright light sources like car headlights or the sun are in the image.

Dash Camera Resolution
The M6 dashcam from Momento features a Sony Exmor-R image sensor with Starvis for excellent low-light performance.

Camera Speed Matters!

If you want to increase your chances of capturing details, one essential feature to look for is a higher frame rate. If you look at how video is captured, it’s essentially a series of still images. When we play the pictures back in quick succession, we see the perception of moving objects. Most dash cameras record at a rate of 25 or 30 frames per second. This means there are 25 or 30 still images recorded for every second of the video. This framerate is very similar to what we see on broadcast television (29.97 frames per second).

If you want to capture those split-second moments when a license plate might be visible, look for a camera that offers 60 fps recording. These cameras take 60 images for every second of video they record, doubling your chances of seeing something crucial. Yes, it will use the storage on the memory card faster. However, storage space isn’t a concern unless you need to go back a check something from a few hours earlier. Plus, large-capacity micro-SD cards aren’t overly expensive.

Image Compression and Video Codecs

Another factor that affects image quality is the video compression settings. Most cameras store videos in MPEG format to make the files compatible with popular computers and smartphones. There are several different settings that the camera manufacturer can configure to determine how much information is stored and how much is discarded to reduce file size. Compared with uncompressed video files, the MPEG format can reduce file sizes by six to 26 times. Some cameras offer options to make global adjustments to compression settings. Again, we suggest using as little as possible to help capture details.

Another advancement in video compression came with the move from the H.264 compression standard to the newer, more efficient H.265 format. The H.265 format offers more video file compression while claiming the same image detail. People will argue the efficacy and fine details with any lossy compression format. Nevertheless, H.265 is worth looking for in your next camera purchase, though its ultimate performance depends on how the manufacturer configures the system.

Wi-Fi Connectivity

While it isn’t a feature specifically related to the image-capturing capabilities of the camera, Wi-Fi connectivity is also an important option. If your dashcam doesn’t have Wi-Fi, then you’ll need to remove the memory card and connect to a computer to view what it’s recorded. If you see something happen and want to share it with the police in short order, being able to connect your phone and download a file in a minute will let you show a video or send a screenshot right away.

I

Dash Camera Resolution
The MiVue 798 from Mio includes Wi-Fi connectivity and features a Sony Starvis image sensor that can capture video with 2.5K resolution.

Pick the Right Dash Camera for Your Needs

Having any dashcam is better than none at all. With that said, the frustration of looking at a blurry or pixelated image when trying to extract information is frustrating. We’ve been there. Drop by your local specialty mobile enhancement retailer today to find out about the dashcams they have available with the options and performance features that will meet your expectations.

This article is written and produced by the team at www.BestCarAudio.com. Reproduction or use of any kind is prohibited without the express written permission of 1sixty8 media.

Filed Under: ARTICLES, Car Audio, RESOURCE LIBRARY

What Does it Mean When a Subwoofer Claims to Work in a Small Enclosure?

Small Enclosure Subwoofer

If there’s a single marketing statement that makes my eye twitch, it’s one that claims a specific subwoofer will “work” in a small enclosure. Contrary to many marketing claims, enclosure volume is directly proportional to low-frequency extension and sound quality. Let’s look at the math and how these tiny enclosures ruin the performance of your subwoofer.

The Backstory on Enclosure Volumes and Subwoofer Size

Many years ago, I flew to Edmonton, Alberta, for a distributor trade show. A friend graciously picked a few of us up in his pickup truck at the airport. As we drove toward the venue, I asked if he’d blown the subwoofer in the system. It didn’t produce any deep bass and sounded sloppy. He said that it was brand-new. I asked what subwoofer it was and what enclosure it was in. He told me it was a very popular name-brand sub (yes, I’m concealing the brand) and that it was in a 0.25-cubic-foot sealed enclosure. I thanked him again for picking us up.

The Relationship between Subwoofer Size and Enclosure Volume

For this article’s purposes, we will focus this discussion on acoustic suspension (sealed) enclosures. From 2-inch midrange drivers to 19-inch monster SPL subwoofers, the relationship between the cone area, suspension compliance (softness) and the volume of air in an enclosure is critical in determining how low the speaker will play. The correlation is so constant that many companies have tweeters that behave differently based on the air volume behind the diaphragm.

As a generalization, we can say that a larger enclosure will produce more low-frequency output. Since the goal of adding a subwoofer is to improve low-frequency extension, limiting this characteristic by putting a large subwoofer in a small enclosure is counterproductive.

Considering how it will sound is an even more important factor in designing a high-performance subwoofer system. We can analyze the calculated Qtc value of a subwoofer system (driver and enclosure) to see how well the cone motion is damped. Many car audio enthusiasts fail to consider this part of an enclosure simulation. This oversight results in subwoofer systems that sound terrible and perform poorly – like the one in my friend’s pickup truck.

We get the following qualifications if we look at the description of different speaker Qtc values from Vance Dickason’s Loudspeaker Design Cookbook.

Small Enclosure Subwoofer

Do you want the subwoofer to stop immediately after the drive signal is removed (Qtc = 0.5), or would you like a bit more upper bass output at the expense of slightly degraded transient performance ( Qtc = 0.707)? Perhaps you want a great deal of output at higher frequencies while sacrificing low-frequency output and cone control (Qtc > 1.0)? While there are simple algebraic formulae to calculate these values based on a chosen subwoofer’s Thiele/Small parameters and the volume of the enclosure, we’ll use our tried and tested BassBox Pro software to generate the volume, F3 or Qtc for our sample subwoofer.

Let’s Model Some Subwoofer Enclosures

We’ll start with a typical high-performance 10-inch subwoofer. This driver has a free-air resonant frequency (Fs) of 29 hertz, an equivalent suspension compliance (Vas) of 35.4 liters and a Qts value of 0.501.

While I like extremely well-damped bass, most car audio enthusiasts want a bit of boom and warmth, so let’s start with a target Qtc of 0.707 for our subwoofer system.

Small Enclosure Subwoofer
The predicted frequency response of our 10-inch subwoofer in an enclosure with a target Qtc of 0.707.

For the above enclosure simulation, the software tells us the subwoofer needs to have a net air volume of 0.833 cubic feet. The resulting F3 frequency will be 45.95 Hz. This is typical of a reasonably sized sealed enclosure for a 10-inch car audio subwoofer.

The manufacturer recommends an enclosure with a net internal volume of 0.53 cubic foot. Let’s see what modeling the driver in this enclosure tells us.

Small Enclosure Subwoofer
The predicted frequency response of our 10-inch subwoofer in an enclosure with a target Qtc of 0.806 in yellow.

The 0.53-cubic-foot enclosure results in a system Qtc of 0.806 and an F3 frequency of 48.86. To put the latter value into perspective, the system output at 30 Hz has been reduced by 1.7 dB. Quite simply, the smaller enclosure isn’t as efficient at low frequencies. This is still a very reasonable enclosure design and will provide good output and reasonable physical power handling for the driver.

Let’s switch to looking at specific enclosure volumes. What happens if we cram this sub into a 0.4-cubic-foot enclosure, as is common with many pickup truck under-seat solutions?

Small Enclosure Subwoofer
The predicted response (green) of our 10-inch subwoofer in a 0.4-cubic-foot enclosure.

We now have a system Qtc value of 0.881 and an F3 frequency of 51.64 hertz. Bass output at 30 hertz is now down 3.2 dB from our original 0.833-cubic-foot enclosure. In real-world terms, we need twice as much for the sub to play as loudly as the same driver in a larger enclosure. More power means that your amplifier has to draw more current from the vehicle’s electrical system.

If you’re pondering the benefit of multiple subwoofers in a small enclosure vs. a single driver in an ideal enclosure, you’re starting to get the picture.

Let’s finish this by looking at what happens when our 10-inch sub is crammed into a 0.25-cubic-foot enclosure.

Small Enclosure Subwoofer
The predicted response (teal) of our 10-inch subwoofer in a 0.25-cubic-foot enclosure.

It isn’t hard to see that the sub doesn’t produce anywhere as much bass as it would from a properly sized enclosure. Specifically, the system Qtc is now at a very undesirable 1.034, and the F3 frequency is at 53.38 hertz. Output at 30 hertz is down by a whopping 6.2 dB compared to the original design. Our original 0.833-cubic-foot design only requires 70.4 watts to reach the same output level as this enclosure. Which do you think the amplifier and electrical system will prefer delivering?

What Does “Works in a Small Enclosure” Mean?

As we decrease the size of the enclosure, the air inside acts as a tighter spring and limits how much the woofer cone can move for a given amount of power. From a sound quality perspective, this tighter spring rings and resonates increasingly as enclosure volume decreases. Look at the increase in output around 90 to 100 Hz. This is caused by the woofer cone continuing to move (ring or resonate) once the input signal has been removed. This unwanted motion wasn’t part of the original audio signal and would be considered distortion. The subwoofer system will sound sloppy and is often described as a “one-note wonder.” In short, it should be avoided.

Let me put this into perspective for you in a different way. The graph below shows the output of a 6.5-inch midrange/midbass speaker mounted in the door of a car or truck. With no high-pass filter applied, it produces more bass (with the same power) at 40 hertz than the 10-inch subwoofer crammed into the small 0.25-cubic-foot enclosure. While a 6.5-inch speaker can’t handle 300 watts of power at 40 hertz, there are typically two in the vehicle. One hundred fifty watts is still a stretch, but I think you get the point. A subwoofer in a very small enclosure isn’t acting like a subwoofer – it’s more of a midbass speaker.

Small Enclosure Subwoofer
The predicted frequency response of a single 6.5-inch woofer mounted in an infinite baffled (door) location in violet.

It’s not much of a stretch to say that stuffing subwoofers into microscopic enclosures is counterproductive. From a perspective of not failing, yes, they work. Do they sound good? No. Do they produce extended low-frequency output? No. Are these enclosures efficient? No. As such, do they make sense? No.

If you’re shopping for a subwoofer system for your vehicle, drop by a local specialty mobile enhancement retailer and work with them to choose a subwoofer system that will be efficient and offer excellent low-frequency extension. They should be able to show you computer simulations of how different drivers perform in an enclosure that works with the space you have available. If you want to hear those 35-hertz bass lines in your favorite music, proper subwoofer enclosure size and construction matter.

This article is written and produced by the team at www.BestCarAudio.com. Reproduction or use of any kind is prohibited without the express written permission of 1sixty8 media.

Filed Under: ARTICLES, Car Audio, RESOURCE LIBRARY

Don’t Forget Aftermarket Options When Buying a New Car or Truck

Aftermarket Options

Are you thinking of buying a new car or truck? Are you interested in a model with heated seats, a remote starter, blind-spot monitoring systems, backup sensors or a backup camera? In many cases, these upgrades are part of a premium option or technology package.

Take a look at a popular vehicle like the Ford F-150. Sure, the XLT comes with alloy wheels and different trim options. Still, for more than $5,000 over the price of an XL, you get rear parking sensors, color-coordinated floor mats, a rearview camera, blind spot monitoring and a few other elements of an advanced driver-assistance system.

What if you’re buying a work truck and want a backup camera? Don’t fret; your local specialty mobile enhancement retailer has exactly what you need. Let’s look at how you can upgrade your new vehicle to make it safer and more convenient.

Backup Camera Upgrades

Seeing what’s behind a pickup truck or SUV when backing up or maneuvering into a parking spot can prevent damage and accidents. Having a backup camera system added is a great way to ensure that you can see what’s behind the vehicle. These camera systems work with either the factory-installed display on an infotainment system, a rearview mirror with a color display or a stand-alone display in a commercial vehicle. In addition, the image from the camera displays automatically as soon as you put the transmission in reverse, so you don’t have to remember to push any buttons.

Aftermarket Options
Companies such as Momento offer high-quality rearview mirrors with integrated displays to let you see the image from a backup camera.

Forward-Facing Camera Upgrades

If you drive a large SUV, pickup truck or commercial vehicle, you may want to ask about adding a forward-facing camera to the front grille or bumper. These cameras can often be integrated similarly to a backup camera with a factory-installed display or an aftermarket rear view mirror. The cameras not only let you park nice and close to a wall or curb, but before you drive away, they let you see objects that might have been left in front of the vehicle.

Parking Sensor Systems

Parking sensors are another great upgrade to help prevent accidents. These small ultrasonic sensors can detect objects as small as a 1-inch signpost and produce a loud beep to let you know something or someone is behind your car or truck. Because these systems command your attention with a warning, they’re called active collision avoidance technologies. You don’t need to remember to use them; they’ll tell you when something needs your attention. You can choose from parking sensor systems for just the rear bumper or premium systems with front and rear sensors. Ask the retailer you’re working with about having the sensors painted to match the bumper cover perfectly, so the system is nearly invisible.

Aftermarket Options
Parking sensor kits from such companies as Brandmotion can be color-matched to your vehicle and warn you about objects or people in your path.

Camera- and Sensor-Based Blind Spot Monitoring Systems

The blind spot is the area beside your vehicle, typically from the B-pillar to where you can see objects in the rearview mirror. If your side mirrors aren’t adjusted properly, a car or motorcycle can be completely invisible to you unless you do a shoulder check. Two types of blind-spot monitoring systems can help prevent accidents when you’re changing lanes and someone is beside you. Camera-based blind spot monitoring systems will show you what’s beside your vehicle when you activate the turn signal. The images from a camera mounted on the side mirror can be shown on the factory infotainment system display or an aftermarket rearview mirror with a built-in color screen.

Aftermarket Options
Echomaster offers several vehicle-specific camera-based blind spot monitoring systems to show someone driving adjacent to you.

Another option for blind spot monitoring is a microwave-based sensor system. These are the most common solutions, and they work similarly to the ones in many new vehicles. A small indicator will illuminate if someone is driving in your blind spot. These indicators are usually mounted at the base of the A-pillars and flash a bright orange light to get your attention. If you activate your turn signal while someone is in this space, the blind spot monitoring system will start beeping to let you know not to change lanes.

Aftermarket Options
Rydeen dealers offer the Cub brand of blind spot monitoring systems, including specific models for popular pickup trucks.

Remote Car Starters

Letting your car or truck run for a few minutes before you drive away on a cold winter morning can save you time and make life easier. Having a remote car starter system makes it easy to warm up the vehicle while you’re putting on your coat and finding your wallet. Likewise, the air conditioning system can run for a few minutes to cool off the interior on a hot summer afternoon. Ask the shop you’re working with about automatic activation of the rear window defroster, heated seats, or a heat steering wheel when the car or truck’s interior is cold.

Aftermarket Options
A high-quality remote car starter from Compustar will let you let your vehicle warm up or cool off to make driving much more comfortable.

Heated Seat Upgrades

Wouldn’t it be nice to have seat heaters in your vehicle for those cold winter mornings? Did you know that they can be added as an aftermarket option to most cars and trucks? High-quality heating elements that use flexible carbon thread elements can be added to the back and bottom of your seats to add warmth. Most of these systems have high and low temperature settings. You can leave the control switch on and the seat heaters will start working with a remote car starter.

Aftermarket Options
Most front and rear seats can be upgraded with high-quality heating kits like this one from Metra Electronics.

Floor Mats and Seat Covers

If you’re buying a new vehicle and want to help maintain its value, ask your mobile enhancement retailer about vehicle-specific floor mats. These molded mats not only help keep water, dirt, sand and slush contained, but they extend up the sides of the footwells to keep the carpet cleaner. Most high-quality mats are available in color options that match the vehicle’s interior and are available for front and back row seating. You can also get matching cargo mats to prevent spills from damaging the trunk or carpet in the back of an SUV.

Aftermarket Options
Protecting the interior of your vehicle with application-specific floor mats such as the ones from WeatherTech will help keep everything clean.

Window Tint and Paint Protection Film

Window tint and paint protection film are two options that car dealers love to encourage new clients to add on. Just as with buying car stereo speakers, you’ll want to research these products before proceeding with a purchase. Window tint quality can vary dramatically. Inexpensive tint can fade quickly, turn purple, bubble and peel. The low-cost tint films also don’t offer much heat rejection compared with premium solutions. If you want your tint to perform, you’re better off dealing with a shop specializing in these upgrades.

Aftermarket Options
Mobile Edge in Lehighton, Pennsylvania, installed 3M Ceramic IR window tint on this 2021 Tesla Model 3 to make it more comfortable.

The same goes for paint protection film, or what’s often called clear bra. These transparent polyurethane films are designed to protect painted surfaces against scratches and chips from gravel and stones, stains from tar and bugs and scuffs from jewelry or long fingernails around door handles. An expert will show you the films that are available and let you choose the surfaces you want to protect. At the very least, the front bumper and, depending on the vehicle design, the hood are good starting points. If you live somewhere where it snows and find yourself kicking your boots on the rocker panels, having those surfaces protected with PPF surfaces is a good idea.

Aftermarket Options
Westminster Speed and Sound in Maryland upgraded this 2018 Corvette with 3M Scotchgard Pro 4.0 paint protection film.

Upgrade Your New Vehicle Today!

Before you check off the box for a technology package with options you don’t want, or have the dealership install window tint, paint film or a car starter, drop by your local specialty mobile enhancement retailer and ask what they have available. You may find much better pricing and much higher-quality solutions. At the very least, you can select the exact features that meet your needs. If there’s an option you want that we didn’t mention, be sure to ask them if it’s available as an aftermarket upgrade.

Lead-In Image Credit: Special thanks to Mat Romain from Wedgeport, Nova Scotia, for the photo of his awesome 2019 GMC Sierra pickup truck! We look forward to seeing the rest of the upgrades you have planned!

This article is written and produced by the team at www.BestCarAudio.com. Reproduction or use of any kind is prohibited without the express written permission of 1sixty8 media.

Filed Under: ARTICLES, Car Audio, Remote Car Starters, RESOURCE LIBRARY, Window Tint

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • …
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 14
  • 15
  • …
  • 78
  • Next Page »

Recent Articles

A cartoon car with rings around it, signifying the ADAS systems detecting the surroundings

A Look at Modern ADAS Technology and Terminology

August 3, 2025 

Shopping for a new car, pickup truck or SUV is impossible without being bombarded with information about ADAS technology. Advanced driver assistance systems are designed to help … [Read More...]

Car trunk open with many red wires pouring out of it

Deep Thoughts on Car Audio Power Wire Sizing

July 27, 2025 

In the 1980s, most car stereo shops had charts in the install bays that showed what size power wire should be used with different amplifiers. Some charts were based on current and … [Read More...]

The Alpine i407-WRA-JL

Product Spotlight: Alpine i407-WRA-JL

July 21, 2025 

If you’ve been paying attention over the last few years, you’ll know that the folks at Alpine have been offering many different audio system upgrade solutions for Jeep Wrangler and … [Read More...]

A lady in front of a large motorcycle with car audio speakers on each side, looking confused

Motorcycle Speakers and Big Bass – A Match Not Made in Heaven

July 20, 2025 

We were recently talking with the owner of a motorcycle audio manufacturer. He mentioned that consumers seem to struggle with the concept that relatively small motorcycle speakers … [Read More...]

Three tweeters

A Look at the Importance of Tweeter Installation Hardware

July 13, 2025 

High-quality speakers and proper installation are crucial when upgrading your car's audio system. The ease with which your installer can reliably integrate tweeters into your … [Read More...]

Customer Reviews

Subscribe to Our Website

Enter your email address to subscribe to our website and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Quakertown Showroom and Installation Facility


Get Directions to Clear Vibrations

Hours

Monday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
SaturdayClosed
SundayClosed

Services

  • Car Audio
  • Custom Installation
  • Fleet Services
  • Driver Safety
  • Remote Car Starters

Connect With Us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2025 Clear Vibrations · Privacy Policy · Website by 1sixty8 media, inc. · Log in

 

Loading Comments...